Sunday, January 27, 2008

Jago Chapter 4

I hate rubrics! Sometimes I forget that grading is going to be a big part of my job as a teacher. Even though they have grading rubrics to follow, I still think that the bullet points in the rubric can be so generic. I mean, what if there is a student who has obviously put a lot of thought and creativity into their essay, but has too many grammar errors? Or what about the papers that have addressed every single point in a rubric, but you can tell that it isn't a heart-felt essay? 

I like the Quotation Reflection Chart. I think that this tool can really help students use their quotations wisely. It can also help get ideas flowing. I like how the chart asks the students to think about how each quote says something about both the book and the world. I think that it helps them practice thinking within two different scopes. It helps students think about the small picture without forgetting about the big picture. I would definitely use a reflection chart like this in my classroom. 

1 comment:

Todd Bannon said...

This is great! I'm glad some of you are passionate in your hatred of rubrics. I'm hoping some of your colleagues are also passionately for them. Our wikispace on rubrics should be fun to read.